Settings to Expire posts Older than “4 years ago” not working

Regardless of the verbiage I have attempted to use, the manual run test does not remove any posts older than 4 years ago. Here is a list of the different ways I have written it to try to get it to work and their manual test result errors:

• 4 years ago - Yellow diamond - no change
• +1460 days - Yellow diamond
• 208 weeks ago - Yellow diamond
• 1460 days ago - Yellow diamond

The log however registers these attempts as "Cleanup succesfully run! 0 posts cleaned-up!" Now when I turned the plugin "Main Switch" to off and ran the "208 weeks ago" and the "4 years ago" options I did get a green checkmark but of course, nothing is deleted with that option. What are we doing wrong? See snapshot attached of current settings. Thank you!